The Gospel of Gain: How Political Idolatry Corrupts the Church

💸The Gospel of Gain: Paula White–Cain and the Prosperity of Pride

(Sheepfold Under Siege — Article 2)

Introduction

False teaching rarely begins with a roar. It begins with a whisper: “God wants you to have more.”

The modern prosperity gospel has taken many forms, but perhaps no figure embodies its fusion of spiritual distortion and political power more fully than Paula White–Cain. Through a ministry shaped by the Word-of-Faith movement, elevated through media, and amplified by presidential proximity, White’s message often drifts from the theology of the cross into the theology of self-exaltation.

Scripture gives its warning plainly:

> “Those who suppose godliness is a means of gain… pierce themselves with many sorrows.”

— 1 Timothy 6:5–10

> “Their god is their belly; they glory in their shame.”

— Philippians 3:18–19

> “You cannot serve God and money.”

— Matthew 6:24

> “All these I will give You, if You will worship me.”

— Luke 4:5–8

With Scripture as our anchor, we examine Paula White’s rise, her doctrine, its fruit, and the path back to the true gospel of Christ crucified.

---

1. The Teacher & Her Appeal — How She Captured the Crowd

Paula White–Cain entered ministry through the Word-of-Faith stream and co-founded Without Walls International Church in Tampa in 1991 with Randy White. Her televangelism program Paula White Today (launched early 2000s) gave her national influence, packaging “seed-faith giving,” promises of breakthrough, and verbal “decrees” into a marketable spirituality.

Her ascent became even more pronounced with political involvement. In 2017, she was widely reported as a spiritual adviser to Donald J. Trump, and in November 2019 she was officially appointed to the White House Faith & Opportunity Initiative.

The Washington Post wrote:

> “White… is one of the most prominent televangelists who teach a prosperity gospel, that God will reward believers with wealth and health.”¹

For many, this made her a symbol of upward mobility, empowerment, and divine favor. But the message that attracts does not always sanctify.

---

2. The Drift — Where the Teaching Breaks

a. Word-of-Faith Positive Confession

Paula White regularly teaches that a believer’s words or faith declarations can “create” reality. This echoes the theology of Kenneth Hagin, Kenneth Copeland, and Benny Hinn.

The Christian Post notes:

> “Her message… frames words as containers of power to shape the world.”²

But Scripture teaches that God creates (Gen 1:1), and believers respond in trust — not creative authority.

b. Prosperity Transaction — ‘Give to Get’

White’s fundraising appeals have included a “$1,144 resurrection seed” linked to John 11:44 and seasonal campaigns promising “seven supernatural blessings” for gifts of $1,000 or more.³

This treats blessing as transactional, contradicting the Reformed understanding of giving as grace-driven generosity, not spiritual purchase (2 Cor 9:7–11).

c. The “Little gods” Doctrine

Paula White has been cited endorsing the idea that believers are “little gods,” reflecting a core Word-of-Faith doctrine.

The Gospel Coalition summarizes:

> “Paula White has used language consistent with the ‘little gods’ teaching.”⁴

But Reformed orthodoxy affirms Creator-creature distinction:

God alone is God.

We are His redeemed creatures — not co-deities.

d. Political Messianism

White often frames political battles in prophetic language. In 2019 she prayed publicly for “demonic networks” opposing President Trump to be destroyed, and once stated Christians would “stand accountable before God” if they voted against him.⁵

This elevates temporal power to near-sacred status — the very temptation Satan offered Christ (Luke 4:5–8).

e. Contrast with Reformed Orthodoxy

Reformed theology insists:

Sola Gratia — Grace, not giving, brings blessing.

Sola Fide — Faith receives; it does not create.

Theology of the Cross — True power is found in weakness, not worldly prominence.

Covenantal Stewardship — Wealth is a trust, not a trophy (Deut 8:18; 1 Tim 6:17–18).

As R. C. Sproul taught:

> “The theology of the cross is the wisdom of God hidden in weakness.”⁶

White’s teaching regularly reverses that order — glory before grace, crown before cross.

---

3. The Fruit — What It Produces

a. Disillusioned, Financially Harmed Believers

Many who give expecting breakthrough never receive the promised return. The Christian Post observes:

> “Her message links financial status to spiritual worth.”²

This creates shame, guilt, and financial ruin.

b. A Church That Measures Favor, Not Faithfulness

Where wealth equals blessing, the poor are ashamed, the struggling are blamed, and faithfulness becomes indistinguishable from success.

c. Political Idolatry

White’s public prayers and prophetic claims tied to the 2020 election became infamous — including the viral “angels from Africa” invocation.⁷ This brought global ridicule upon the gospel.

d. A Compromised Witness

Instead of Christ-centered humility, White’s ministry celebrates prominence, wealth, and political proximity. Such fruit contradicts the way of the crucified Christ.

---

4. The Call — Pastoral Exhortation

Beloved, the path forward is not outrage — but repentance, sobriety and return to the Scriptures.

John Calvin warns:

> “Where riches hold the dominion of the heart, God has lost His authority.”⁸

Therefore:

Measure success by faithfulness, not fame.

Discern teachers who trade providence for profit.

Reject political messianism in all forms.

Return to the theology of the cross.

Remember that grace cannot be bought, bartered, or brokered.

Christ is our treasure — not money, not access, not influence.

To the weary who have been wounded by prosperity teaching:

Come home.

The grace of Christ is free.

The favor of God is not bought.

The kingdom of Christ is not of this world.

> “When the preacher turns profit into proof of piety, she no longer points to Christ’s cross—but to her own crown.”

May Christ restore His sheep, purify His church, and guard His fold.

---

Citations & Sources

1. Washington Post, “Trump’s Key Spiritual Adviser Paula White Joins White House Faith Initiative,” Nov. 1, 2019.

2. Christian Post, “Paula White’s Prosperity Gospel Twists Scripture for Profit,” 2020.

3. Christian Post, “Televangelist Paula White Hawks $1,144 ‘Resurrection Seed’,” 2016.

4. The Gospel Coalition, “9 Things You Should Know About Prosperity Preacher Paula White,” 2019.

5. Washington Post, “Paula White at Trump Rally: ‘Demonic Networks Must Be Broken’,” June 2019.

6. R. C. Sproul, Tabletalk Magazine, “The Theology of the Cross vs. the Theology of Glory.”

7. The Roys Report, “Paula White Calls Angels from Africa to Secure the Election,” Nov 5, 2020 (includes video verification).

8. John Calvin, Commentary on Luke 12:15.

✒️ The Pilgrim’s Post